Skip to main content

Prof. Hovy’s criteria for a dissertation defenses

dissertation
research
Author

Abe Kazemzadeh

Published

September 21, 2011

I recently attended a dissertation defense and Prof. Eduard Hovy was one of the committee members.  He mentioned a set of criteria that he uses to evaluate defenses.  Although I did not write them down quickly enough, he was kind enough to send them to me when I asked.   I’m posting them here so that help other students evaluate their own work before they present and defend it.

Prof. Hovy’s 6 criteria:

1. Is this a real problem?
2. Is there a real idea/insight in the work? (creativity)
3. Has the solution been worked out sufficiently? (scope)
4. Does the student master the methodology of the field? (procedures and tools)
5. Are references to past work adequate? (depth and breadth of knowledge)
6. Can the student communicate the work? (writing and presentations)


Originally published on abewrites.

clustrmaps.html